Skip to content

Same-writer pending version continuity (1.5 breaking change)

A standing newer value published by a writer can require rechecking after its independent supporting source is withdrawn. The value remains a hint; the store does not trust that pending publication. On the newer publication's validity span, however, the same writer's older different value no longer certifies an answer. This creates a temporal gap, rather than silently serving the obsolete value. A pending assertion from a different writer cannot create this gap in another writer's clean support.

For example, product_team first says warranty=36 from day0, then says24 from day120 while an independently checked vendor supports24. If the vendor is withdrawn and the team copy becomes pending, a read at126 now returns no fact from either claim. It still returns36 before120. The caller can obtain a fresh independent verdict and call native retest(id, ok=True, by=...) to make24 eligible. No label, identity, permission, trust or re-test is fabricated automatically.

The gap only covers the standing pending version's bounded interval. If that later assertion is actually withdrawn, the old version reopens as before. Old claims from an independent writer remain eligible under existing resolution. Flags, retirement, premise/consulted taints and source/write gates are unchanged. periods, usable(valid_at=...), time-specific snapshots, derived periods, rebuild and branches use the same effective intervals. Reads without a world time retain their documented status-only behavior; applications needing temporal answers must supply valid_at or the store's explicit world clock.

This intentionally differs from 1.4's older-value fallback. It fixes an unsafe host answer, not the truth of the later copy: abstention is still different from the known gold value. The frozen corpus performance/quality result remains negative; this focused migration does not establish a new corpus pass.

Continuity clipping changes occupancy only: a fragment reopening at the end of a gap retains its ORIGINAL version-start priority. It cannot outrank an independent clean version published between the original start and the gap end. Undated clean support is preserved when no matching same-writer restriction applies. Derived, inferred and consulted older contributions are not direct declarations and are not clipped by this continuity rule; their existing dependency gates decide them.